We specialize in fondant decorated cakes, but are expanding our buttercream cake offerings. If you have an idea for a cake, please inquire as to if it is a design that is available in buttercream.
*Buttercream decorated cakes are priced per serving at $2.00 each. For design reasons, some decorations may be best made out of fondant, and those cakes will be priced on an individual basis (approximately $5-$10 per cake depending on the amount of fondant decorations).
*Fondant decorated cakes are priced per serving at $3.00 each.
*Cookie decorated cakes are priced per serving at $1.00 each plus the cookie price.
Price includes any design, flavor, and filling choice.
All 1st birthday cakes come with a free smash cake!
There is an additional charge for tiered cakes (internal supports)
based on the size of the cake (approximately $5 to $20).
If you cut your cake pieces large, you will probably want to order up a size. The prices and servings listed below are for double layer cakes, except sheet cakes which are available as single layers only.
*Note: The smallest individual cake order is 8" or 1/4 sheet.
For a great cutting guide, please click here and visit Sweet Art Shop by Gabby Colindres, a wonderful cake decorator in Florida. She has a fabulous step-by-step photo guide for how to cut a cake. This is the correct way to cut a cake, as if you cut your cake like a pie, you will not have enough servings.

Sugar bows, whimsical flowers, unique textures.....just some of the techniques we will use to create a cake just for you! Our cakes will never be frozen and are baked from scratch, and our buttercream (with real butter!) will be made fresh for your order. We want to give you the best we have to offer in taste, design, and price. Call Michelle today at 330-351-9708 or email at Michelle@SugarHouseCookies.com .
Round 6" 12
Square 6" 12
8" 20
10" 30
12" 48
Sheet 1/4 20 (single layer only)
1/2 35 (single layer only)
Shape Size Servings
Cupcakes: Minimum of two dozen per order, one flavor per two dozen.
$1.00 each for buttercream iced; with or without sprinkles.
$1.25 each for buttercream iced with sugar decoration.
$1.50 each for buttercream iced with cookie decoration
Please email us Michelle@SugarHouseCookies.com to place your order. As we can only take on a so many orders per week, reserve your date with a 50% deposit as soon as possible, which is nonrefundable after we begin to create sugar pieces and/or bake for your order. Remainder of bill is due 7 days before your order is due. Less than 7 days before delivery requires payment in full at time of order.
Buttercream Flavors:
Vanilla
Chocolate
Cake Flavors:
Yellow
Chocolate
Marble
Carrot*
Filling Flavors:
Raspberry Preserve
Strawberry Preserve
Orange Preserve
Raspberry Cream
Strawberry Cream
Orange Cream
Cookies & Cream (vanilla or chocolate)
Peppermint (vanilla or chocolate)
Other flavors may be available upon request. * Available in 8" round double layer or cupcakes only.
Giant Decorated Chocolate Chip Cookie: $15 for a 10" round.
Please note that it is illegal to replicate any copyright image (i.e. Disney characters, cartoon characters, etc.) unless you are the owner of that image or have permission to use it (business logos for example). Lots of bakeries do it, but we will not risk our business. We are unable to make any cakes in the likeness of a copyrighted/licensed character, but will design a cake based on a particular party theme if you desire. You may, however, purchase your own character figurines (Disney figurines, cartoon character figurines, etc.) and we will leave special areas on the cake for you to place them.
Dessert Cakes
$25 8" double layer round
Cream cheese
Pineapple
Coconut
Peanut Butter Cup
Caramel
This Page Is Under Construction! We are currently not taking cake orders.
Buttercream Flavors:
Vanilla
Chocolate
Cupcake Flavors:
Yellow
Chocolate
Filling Flavors:
Raspberry Cream
Strawberry Cream
Orange Cream
Cookies & Cream (vanilla or chocolate)
Peppermint (vanilla or chocolate)